Good guys and guns

So, I’ve been thinking a lot about how all these good guys with guns are supposed to protect us from bad guys with guns.  You know what?  They already are– they are called police officers.  As for the rest of the good guys with guns?  They are already out there and not stopping the now-regular drumbeat of mass shootings.  Pretty much everybody who wants to pack heat in their daily life and be one of those “good guys” can quite readily do so.  Concealed carry laws are everywhere and pretty much anybody can buy a gun.  So, why aren’t more “good guys” saving us?  Because the truth is very few Americans actually want to live in a Wild West society where the only thing protecting us is an absurdly high frequency of ordinary citizens armed with guns.  The vast majority of Americans don’t want to be that guy carrying their gun everywhere in case there is a maniac about.  Again, those that do probably already are because there is nothing in the law stopping them.  And clearly, there’s not nearly enough of them to stop the disturbingly regular mass shootings (not to mention all the far more common and far more “ordinary” gun crime).  So, the “more guns, less crime” argument (already pretty well shot down by research) just does not hold up to logical scrutiny under our present legal regime.  What might help?  Less guns and a far more serious approach to regulating them.

About Steve Greene
Professor of Political Science at NC State http://faculty.chass.ncsu.edu/shgreene

3 Responses to Good guys and guns

  1. itchy says:

    It’s worse. Good guys with guns kill other people. Accidentally, mistakenly, purposely. Good guys with guns kill other good guys with guns, because they can’t tell the differerence between a good guy with a gun and a guy with a gun. Or a guy who might have a gun. Or a guy who pisses them off. Or does something odd. Or doesn’t quite look right.

    Most mass shootings have been by self-proclaimed good guys with guns … at least, up until the point where he shot people.

  2. rgbact says:

    “more guns, less crime” doesn’t hold?? How so? Murder rate is at a 100 year low. The only thing up is these mass shootings, which are rare but get lots of media. and half of those are Muslim extremism.

Leave a comment