January 31, 2016 Leave a comment
1) Vox’s Amanda Taub has come to the same conclusion as me… Trump is using “political correctness” as an excuse for just being a jerk.
2) When you consider how common wisdom teeth extraction is, it almost has to be an overused medical procedure (I had mine out when I was 23 and it took me out of commission for the better part of a week). What I really want to know is what are the outcomes in poor countries where people are not routinely having these teeth removed (though, surely there’s a lot of confounds with that). Still, I cannot believe this many Americans have been this poorly served by evolution.
3) Loved this column on how the lead in Flint problem is a direct result of “small government” ideology.
4) Really interesting summary of a new book that focuses on American slavery as a slave breeding industry.
5) Michael Tesler on what a new poll shows about the populist appeal of Trump.
6) NPR story on the new research finding systematic bias against women in teaching evaluations. I don’t doubt this is a genuine problem we should think about, but I’m still waiting for professors who get good evaluations to say they are worthless and professors with poor evaluations to admit maybe there is some value to them:
“That the situation is Really Complicated,” Philip Stark writes in an email to NPR Ed, and, he adds, it won’t be easy to correct for it. In fact, the authors titled their paper “Student Evaluations of Teaching (Mostly) Do Not Measure Teaching Effectiveness.”
These results seem pretty damning, but not everyone is convinced.
Michael Grant is the vice provost and associate vice chancellor for undergraduate education at the University of Colorado, Boulder. He says there’s a lot of research supporting the effectiveness and usefulness of student evaluations.
“There are multiple, well-designed, thoughtfully conducted studies that clearly contradict this very weakly designed study,” he says, citing this study from 2000 andthis study conducted at his own university. His personal review of student ratings from one department at CU Boulder over nine years did find a bias in favor of men, he says, but it was very small — averaging 0.13 on a 6-point scale.
7) Teller of Penn & Teller was a high school Latin teacher before becoming a famous magician. His take on how teaching is like performing magic.
8) Some common-sense recommendations for being more humane with how we wean cows. Good for the cows; good for the farmers; good for the conscience of conflicted meat-eaters. We really should do far more to ensure that our meat food supply is generated in a humane manner.
9) Really interesting piece on the evolution of single-sex bathrooms:
Today’s most-prominent arguments against inclusive restrooms are remarkably consistent with the Victorian notions that led to sex-segregated bathrooms in the first place. When the ideology of separate spheres for male and female, public and private, the market and the home reigned, the growth of women’s presence in public life led to the desire to protect women from the crude dangers of the male world. Among the legal effects was the 1873 Supreme Court holding in Bradwell v. Illinois that it was not unconstitutional for a state to deny women admission to the bar on the basis of their sex, with a famous concurring opinion that stated, “Man is, or should be, woman’s protector and defender. The natural and proper timidity and delicacy which belongs to the female sex evidently unfits it for many of the occupations of civil life.” The same separate-spheres paternalism led to the designation of certain physical spaces for women apart from those for men, including bathrooms in public venues. These were safe spaces, if you will, tucked in a world in which women were vulnerable. As our society is currently experiencing a resurgence of paternalist concern about women’s sexual vulnerability—especially in the context of that great equalizer, education—it is no surprise that there would also be a new emphasis on the Victorian phenomenon of separate restrooms.
10) Great story on the Virginia Tech professor who was crucial to uncovering the Flint water problems.
11) I’m planning on reading Neurotribes and I expect to learn a lot from it. That said, based on articles about the book and interviews with the author, the book seems to very much elide how substantially and severely very many people and families are affected by autism.
12) Former Defense Secretary Robert Gates on foreign policy of Republican presidential aspirants:
Robert Gates , a Republican stalwart and former US defence secretary who served under eight presidents, has derided the party’s election candidates for a grasp of national security issues that “would embarrass a middle schooler”.
An ex-CIA director who first joined the White House under Richard Nixon, Gates joked that if frontrunner Donald Trump wins the presidency, he would emigrate to Canada. He condemned the media for failing to challenge candidates from both parties on promises he believes are unaffordable, illegal or unconstitutional.
“The level of dialogue on national security issues would embarrass a middle schooler,” Gates said of the Republican contenders at a Politico Playbook event in Washington on Monday . “People are out there making threats and promises that are totally unrealistic, totally unattainable. Either they really believe what they’re saying or they’re cynical and opportunistic and, in a way, you hope it’s the latter because God forbid they actually believe some of the things that they’re saying.” [emphasis mine]
13) Can’t say I’m all that surprised to learn that exercise far surpasses all other treatments in effectively reducing back pain.
14) Loved this John McWhorter piece on how it is not at all simple to separate a language from a dialect. I had no idea. It’s been sitting in an open tab deserving it’s own post for too long:
I have a Swedish pal I see at conferences in Denmark. When we’re out and about there, he is at no linguistic disadvantage. He casually orders food and asks directions in Swedish despite the fact that we are in a different country from his own, where supposedly a different “language”—Danish—is spoken. In fact, I’ve watched speakers of Swedish, Danish, and Norwegian conversing with each other, each in their own native tongues, as a cozy little trio over drinks. A Dane who moves to Sweden does not take Swedish lessons; she adjusts to a variation upon, and not an alternate to, her native speech. The speakers of these varieties of Scandinavian consider them distinct languages because they are spoken in distinct nations, and so be it. However, there is nothing about Swedish, Danish, and Norwegian in themselves that classifies them as “languages;” especially on the page, they resemble each other closely enough to look more like dialects of one “language.”
15) Nice Pew summary with cool charts of demographic trends affecting politics.
16) Good piece on how Trump represents a disappearing America from Heather Digby Parton.
17) I want my genetically-modified mosquitoes! A great way to fight mosquito-borne disease, but facing great resistance from un-trusting populations. Yes, there’s uncertainties and things could go wrong. If I lived in an area where people were regularly facing death and debilitation from tropical disease, I’d take the chance.
18) Just finished re-reading Animal Farm for the first time in about 30 years. What an absolutely delightful and brilliant book. My only complaint is that it was too short– I didn’t want it to end.
19) Nice Wonkblog summary on what scientific research can tell us about marijuana. Short version: not a lot to worry about. There is a reasonable debate to be had about legalizing drugs such as heroin and cocaine (and I’m increasingly of the legalize everything perspective), but with marijuana, it’s hardly even a reasonable debate anymore. In a country where alcohol is legal, it is preposterous that marijuana is not. Also, the Wonkblog post on the research suggesting that marijuana does not, after all, affect IQ from teenage use (not that I’ll be giving it to my own teenagers any time soon).
20)And your Sunday long-read– terrific piece from John Judis on Trump, Sanders, and the meaning of populism in America.