Let’s do this 

NPR’s Planet Money interviewed economist Paul Roper about what do do about our current crisis and his ideas about a far more proactive federal role make a hell of a lot of sense.  Like, hey– let’s do these things!  To wit:

But Romer believes that if the federal government pursues a new strategy, where it coordinates industry, sets up and staffs testing sites, and buys virus-fighting equipment at massive scale, we can have a way better option within a month or two.

The way he sees it, the current two choices aren’t nearly as good. One is continued social distancing until scientists deliver us a vaccine available for widespread use, which could take two years. Waiting that long, Romer says, would mean “the end of the economy and life as we know it.”

The other choice is returning to normal before we get a vaccine, with everybody reintegrating into work and social life at the risk of hundreds of thousands of deaths. “We’re either gonna keep destroying the economy or we’re gonna start killing people,” he says…

Romer and Garber advocate that the federal government mobilize the nation like it’s a war and implement measures that might allow us to reenter a somewhat normally functioning economy without massive loss of life.

As others have been advocating, they want the government to make COVID-19 tests universally available, done frequently, and used as a green light for each of us to reenter economic and social life. The problem, Romer says, is there are only about a hundred testing machines in the U.S. and we need at least 5,000 of them. And that “isn’t going to happen if we just sit around and pray and hope,” he says. He thinks it’s going to require massive government funding and centralized direction. He envisions government-sponsored testing sites throughout the country.

Romer and Garber also want mass production of face masks, gloves, full-body suits, hand sanitizer, ventilators, and everything it takes to make it safer for social interaction. “It’s just a tragedy that we don’t have enough masks and face shields – and god help us – we may not even have enough gloves soon for people to do their work at the hospital,” Romer says.

Economists usually like it when the market provides solutions. But building factories, buying machines, training workers, and doing everything else it takes to produce massive quantities of medical equipment on an aggressively short timeline will cost a lot. And, Romer says, without government intervention, companies won’t do this on their own.

That’s because corporate America naturally worries that demand for this equipment will evaporate once the crisis recedes and that even during the crisis, they might not be able to charge much for it. With historically high demand and limited supply, the market’s natural response is sky-high prices. Everybody hates them, but high prices provide an incentive for manufacturers to produce. Yet, Romer says, “the reality is our political system, our emotions, will not let companies charge like ten times as much for the masks right now as we’re trying to get a surge in production. So that’s why the market can’t do its job. We won’t let prices do what they have to do.”

With corporate America caught between a short demand spike and price controls, Romer and Garber want the federal government to step in and do whatever it takes to increase the production of testing machines and protective equipment. Romer compares it to what the government did after Pearl Harbor.

This strikes me as sensible as a matter of health care, economics, and politics.  Alas, I’m afraid the fly in the ointment is that too many Republicans– including the president– are simply opposed to using the federal government in this way even though it represents, quite possibly, the best way out of this mess.

I was kind of depressed thinking about things today because I keep seeing good plans that, in large part, rely on a smart and massive response of the federal government.  And, yet, it seems that with our current leadership we are quite unlikely to get what we so clearly need.

About Steve Greene
Professor of Political Science at NC State http://faculty.chass.ncsu.edu/shgreene

One Response to Let’s do this 

  1. R. Jenrette says:

    Time to bring back the chant – “Hey, hey, Donald J – how many folks did you kill today?”
    Dang, we can’t even protest these days since we have to stay 6 feet apart.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: