Morality and money

Loved this post by Yglesias on the morality of making money.  I think this is a nice example of where his background as a Philosophy major really allows him to bring a fresh perspective you don’t get a lot of.  As always, the whole post is worth your time, but here’s my favorite parts:

But if I look at America today, what I see undermining any meaningful notion of work ethic is a kind of run-amok ethic of moneymaking. The old Calvinist idea about money, as I understood it, was that hard work, discipline, and prudence were moral virtues. They were also things that are more likely than not to lead to personal prosperity. So prosperity shouldn’t be stigmatized as ignoble, it should be rather seen as something likely to flow from virtuous behavior. But this equation assumes that morally speaking what matters is the hard work, the discipline, and the prudence. Cutting corners, lying, cheating, or stealing to make a quick buck doesn’t fit the bill. Earning a multi-million dollar salary to deliver below-average performance as the CEO of a firm and then take a multi-million dollar golden parachute when you get sacked doesn’t fit the bill. Spending your days and nights dreaming up smart regulatory arbitrage schemes doesn’t fit the bill. In terms of what it says about your personal virtue, if you’re going to earn your keep identifying and exploiting previously unknown loopholes in the legal framework, you may as well just go out and break the law…

But the idea is aloft that business executives actually have a moral obligation to spend their days finding ways to engage in profit-maximizing rent-seeking and loophole exploiting. This kind of “you should make as much money as possible through any legal means necessary” spirit is toxic to the kind of ethos that’s made the various forms of modern industrial capitalism successful…

A well-designed welfare state is an excellent thing to have, but to have a culture that valorizes hard work you need to actuallyvalorize hard work not just money-making.

Actually, I’d think there might be some interesting cross-national survey data on this point– ideas on the morality of simply making money versus hard work.  If there’s not, there should be.

Advertisements
%d bloggers like this: