Mosque timeline

I feel kind of lame blogging about the Islamic Center so much, but I think it is a really striking, and depressing, window on how dysfunctional our national politics have become.  Of course, one of the major features of current political discourse is how ultimately trivial issues our amplified by the right-wing noise machine until they are picked up by the mainstream media and become what everybody is talking about.  There’s surely 100 things more important to our nation than whether an Islamic Center & Mosque is built 2 blocks from the WTC site, but that’s the number one thing in the news now.  Salon’s Justin Elliot does a real service by creating a timeline and showing just how this issue blew up.  Some highlights:

Dec. 21, 2009: Conservative media personality Laura Ingraham interviews Abdul Rauf’s wife, Daisy Khan, while guest-hosting “The O’Reilly Factor” on Fox. In hindsight, the segment is remarkable for its cordiality. “I can’t find many people who really have a problem with it,” Ingraham says of the Cordoba project, adding at the end of the interview, “I like what you’re trying to do.”

(This segment also includes onscreen the first use that we’ve seen of the misnomer “ground zero mosque.”) After the segment — and despite the front-page Times story — there were no news articles on the mosque for five and a half months, according to a search of the Nexis newspaper archive.

May 6, 2010: After a unanimous vote by a New York City community board committee to approve the project, the AP runs a story. It quotes relatives of 9/11 victims (called by the reporter), who offer differing opinions. The New York Post, meanwhile, runs a story under the inaccurate headline, “Panel Approves ‘WTC’ Mosque.” Geller is less subtle, titling her post that day, “Monster Mosque Pushes Ahead in Shadow of World Trade Center Islamic Death and Destruction.”…

May 13, 2010: Peyser follows up with an entire column devoted to “Mosque Madness at Ground Zero.” This is a significant moment in the development of the “ground zero mosque” narrative: It’s the first newspaper article that frames the project as inherently wrong and suspect, in the way that Geller has been framing it for months. Peyser in fact quotes Geller at length and promotes the anti-mosque protest of Stop Islamization of America, which Peyser describes as a “human-rights group.” Peyser also reports — falsely — that Cordoba House’s opening date will be Sept. 11, 2011…

Within a month, Rudy Giuliani had called the mosque a “desecration.” Within another month, Sarah Palin had tweeted her famous “peaceful Muslims, pls refudiate” tweet. Peter King and Newt Gingrich and Tim Pawlenty followed suit — with political reporters and television news programs dutifully covering “both sides” of the controversy.

Ultimately, a depressingly familiar story.  Right-wing media obsesses on fear-mongering issue.  Professional fear-mongers like Gingrich and Palin expand the story.  Mainstream media covers “the controversy.”   Sad and pathetic.  And effective.  I really wish more (there are some) reasonable conservatives would denounce this demagoguery.  That failure depresses (though no longer surprises) me as much as anything.

About Steve Greene
Professor of Political Science at NC State

6 Responses to Mosque timeline

  1. jonolan says:

    You wish that some “reasonable” conservatives would denounce this demagoguery? Funny, I wish some rational liberals would recognize their own hypocrisy on this issue.

    But then “reasonable” normally really means weak-willed and compliant when spoken by a liberal and rational seems to be rarely in their lexicon.

    It’s amazing really; libs regularly get all “up in arms” over supposed outrages when it’s over something that Whites or Christians or Jews do, but always seem to jump to defend any action by “brown people” and/or Muslims.

    But then Libs only seem to approve of cultural sensitivities when the culture involved isn’t American.

    • Steve Greene says:

      Funny, that couldn’t have been less convincing. Muslims doing bad things = bad. Minorities doing bad things = bad. Happy? Christians and Jews doing bad things = bad. In just in case you hadn’t notice, the context is quite different when the dominant and politically powerful groups in a society do something than when minority groups do something.

      • jonolan says:

        Just in case you hadn’t noticed, the context is exactly the same when the dominant and politically powerful groups in a society do something as when minority groups do something. It has something to do with the idea of “equality,” something Liberals have twisted all out of shape in their minds.

  2. I arrived here from the WP Recent Posts board and decided to look around.

    I find this controversy interesting. I live in the Philippines and it is my first time to hear of this particular issue. I wont presume to know how Americans feel about the mosque so I wont comment on that. However, I agree: “Muslims doing bad things = bad”.

    I am a Christian and I live in Mindanao. We have a long running internal conflict, which some of those living outside Mindanao think is a battle between Christians and Moslems. I have always insisted that it is not.

    It scares me that we are starting to judge people because of their creed instead of their particular acts.

    • Steve Greene says:

      Not “starting to judge.” This is what we do– it’s human nature. Some of us work to overcome it, other’s embrace it (much like stereotyping). Check out the minimal group paradigm:

      • Yes, you are right. I just feel that it got more wind after “war against terror” was coined and, somehow, Islam became tinged with terrorism.

        This is sad because it heightens the feeling of discrimination Moslems already feel in our area. Fear-mongering and stereotyping makes it awkward (sometimes dangerous) for us who live in mixed communities.

        Thanks for posting and replying, Steve.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: